A Bailout Rogues Gallery . . .
. . . Or for those who preferred the “rescue package,” the Members of Congress listed below are a group who saw the light. Or they were strong-armed by their party leadership. Or they horse-traded their support for some benefit to themselves or their districts.
Each of these explanations may be true in one or another case. Americans will tend to prefer the story that fits the ideological and policy positions they already had, just like most people think that the winner of last Thursday’s debate was the vice presidential candidate they already liked.
But, with just a month to go before the election, the passage of the financial services bailout gives voters a chance to make clear their preferences in Washington’s policies, and in the behavior of their representatives.
Below, we’ve compiled the list of congressmembers who changed their votes between Monday and Friday last week. Collectively, they allowed the $700,000,000,000 financial services bailout bill to pass and become law. We’ve also listed their opponents in the upcoming election, who may gain or lose ground based on the incumbent’s treatment of this very important issue.
Click below to jump to your state and see if your representative, or someone that represents friends or family members, was one of the now infamous vote-switchers. And what are you going to do about it? Give them a piece of your mind? Donate to them or their opponents? Write a letter to your local paper? That’s up to you.
[Update: In collecting images and data for this posted, we originally treated Rep. Julia Carson as the representative from Indiana's 7th District. Her grandson Andre Carson took her place when she passed away, and his image and information has now taken the place of hers below. Embarrassing error.]
[Update II: A list of all votes in order of state and congressional districts is here.]
[Update III: A Web site for Vermont challenger Jerry Trudell has been added. Yes, a wee bit late.]
Arizona, California, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Vermont.
Arizona
Rep. Gabrielle Giffords of Tucson, Arizona (8th District) Democrat—1 term
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Tim Bee (R)
Paul Davis (Libertarian)
Rep. Harry E. Mitchell of Tempe, Arizona (5th District) Democrat—1 term
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
David Schweikert (R)
Warren D. Severin (Libertarian)
Rep. Ed Pastor of Phoenix, Arizona (4th District) Democrat—9 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Joe Cobb (Libertarian)
Don Karg (R)
Rebecca S. Dewitt (Green)
Rep. John B. Shadegg of Phoenix, Arizona (3d District) Republican—7 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Bob Lord (D)
Michael Shoen (Libertarian)
California
Rep. Joe Baca of Rialto, California (43d District) Democrat—5 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
John Roberts (R)
Rep. Barbara Lee of Oakland, California (9th District) Democrat—6 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Jim Eyer (Libertarian)
Charles R. Hargrave (R)
Rep. Adam B. Schiff of Burbank, California (29th District) Democrat—4 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Charles Hahn (R)
Alan Pyeatt (Libertarian)
Rep. Hilda L. Solis of El Monte, California (32d District) Democrat—4 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
none found
Rep. Mike Thompson of St. Helena, California (1st District) Democrat—5 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Zane Starkewolf (R)
Carol S. Wolman (Green)
Rep. Diane E. Watson of Los Angeles, California (33d District) Democrat—4 terms
Official Site
Opponent(s):
David C. Crowley (R)
Rep. Lynn C. Woolsey of Petaluma, California (6th District) Democrat—8 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Michael J. ‘Mike’ Halliwell (R)
Joel R. Smolen (Libertarian)(R)
Florida
Rep. Vern Buchanan of Sarasota, Florida (13th District) Republican—1 term
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Don Baldauf
Christine Jennings (D)
Jan Schneider
Rep. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen of Miami, Florida (18th District) Republican—10 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Annette Taddeo (D)
Georgia
Rep. John Lewis of Atlanta, Georgia (5th District) Democrat—11 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
none found
Rep. David Scott of Atlanta, Georgia (13th District) Democrat—3 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Deborah A. Honeycutt (R)
Hawaii
Rep. Neil Abercrombie of Honolulu, Hawaii (1st District) Democrat—10 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Steve Tataii (R)
Li Zhao (Libertarian)
Rep. Mazie K. Hirono of Honolulu, Hawaii (2d District) Democrat—1 term
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Roger B. Evans (R)
Lloyd Jeffrey ‘Jeff’ Mallan (Libertarian)
Shaun Stenshol (Independent)
Illinois
Rep. Judy Biggert of Hinsdale, Illinois (13th District) Republican—5 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Steve Alesch (Green)
Scott Harper (D)
Rep. Jesse L. Jackson, Jr. of Chicago, Illinois (2d District) Democrat—7 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Anthony W. Williams (R)
Rep. Bobby L. Rush of Chicago, Illinois (1st District) Democrat—8 terms
Official Site
Opponent(s):
Antoine Members (R)
Rep. Jerry Weller of Morris, Illinois (11th District) Republican—7 terms
*previously didn’t vote
Official Site
not running for reelection
Opponent(s):
Debbie Halvorson (D)
Marty Ozinga (R)
Jason Wallace (Green)
Indiana
Rep. Andre Carson, of Indianapolis, Indiana (7th District) Democrat—1 term
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Gabrielle Campo (R)
Iowa
Rep. Bruce L. Braley of Waterloo, Iowa (1st District) Democrat—1 term
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
David Hartsuch (R)
Kentucky
Rep. John A. Yarmuth of Louisville, Kentucky (3d District) Democrat—1 term
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Edward Martin (Libertarian)
Anne M. Northup (R)
Louisiana
Rep. Rodney Alexander of Quitman, Louisiana (5th District) Republican—3 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Andrew Clack (R)
Rep. Charles W. Boustany of Lafayette, Louisiana (7th District) Republican—2 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Donald R. “Don” Cravins Jr. (D)
Peter Vidrine
Maryland
Rep. Elijah E. Cummings of Baltimore, Maryland (7th District) Democrat—7 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Michael T. Hargadon (R)
Ronald M. Owens-Bey (Libertarian)
Rep. Donna Edwards of Prince George’s County, Maryland (4th District) Democrat—1 term
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Peter James (R)
Thibeaux Lincecum (Libertarian)
Massachusetts
Rep. John F. Tierney of Salem, Massachusetts (6th District) Democrat—6 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Richard A. Baker (R)
Michigan
Rep. Peter Hoekstra of Holland, Michigan (2d District) Republican—8 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Ronald E. Graeser (U.S. Taxpayers)
Fred Johnson (D)
Dan Johnson (Libertarian)
Rep. Carolyn C. Kilpatrick of Detroit, Michigan (13th District) Democrat—6 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
George L. Corsetti (Green Party)
Gregory Creswell (Libertarian)
Edward Gubics (R)
Rep. Joe Knollenberg of Bloomfield Hills, Michigan (9th District) Republican—8 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Douglas Campbell (Green Party)
Adam Goodman (Libertarian)
Jack Kevorkian
Gary C. Peters (D)
Minnesota
Rep. Jim Ramstad of Minnetonka, Minnesota (3d District) Republican—9 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site (announcing retirement)
Opponent(s):
Ashwin Madia
Erik Paulsen (R)
David Dillon
Missouri
Rep. Emanuel Cleaver of Kansas City, Missouri (5th District) Democrat—2 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Jacob Turk (R)
Nebraska
Rep. Lee Terry of Omaha, Nebraska (2d District) Republican—5 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Jim Esch (D)
Nevada
Rep. Shelley Berkley of Las Vegas, Nevada (1st District) Democrat—5 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Caren Alexander (American Independent)
Raymond J. “Jim” Duensing (Libertarian)
Kenneth A. Wegner (R)
New Jersey
Rep. Rodney P. Frelinghuysen of Morristown, New Jersey (11th District) Republican—7 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Chandler Tedholm (For the People)
Tom Wyka (D)
Rep. Bill Pascrell, Jr. of Paterson, New Jersey (8th District) Democrat—6 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Derek DeMarco (Libertarian)
Roland ‘Rollie’ Straten (R)
New York
Rep. John R. “Randy” Kuhl, Jr. of Hammondsport, New York (29th District) Republican—2 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Eric J. Massa (D, Working Families)
North Carolina
Rep. Howard Coble of Greensboro, North Carolina (6th District) Republican—12 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Teresa S. Bratton (D)
Rep. Sue Wilkins Myrick of Charlotte, North Carolina (9th District) Republican—7 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Andy Grum (Libertarian)
Harry Taylor (D)
Ohio
Rep. Jean Schmidt of Miami Township, Ohio (2d District) Republican—2 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
David H. Krikorian (Independent)
Victoria Wells Wulsin (D)
Rep. Betty Sutton of Copley, Ohio (13th District) Democrat—1 term
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
David S. Potter (R)
Rep. Patrick J. Tiberi, of Galena, Ohio (12th District) Republican—4 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Steve Linnabary (Libertarian)
David Robinson (D)
Oklahoma
Rep. Mary Fallin of Tecumseh, Oklahoma (5th District) Republican—1 term
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Steven L. Perry (D)
Rep. John Sullivan of Tulsa, Oklahoma (1st District) Republican—4 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Georgianna W. Oliver (D)
Oregon
Rep. David Wu of Portland, Oregon (1st District) Democrat—5 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Joel Haugen (Independent)
Chris Henry (Pacific Green)
Scott Semrau (Constitution)
H. Joe Tabor (Libertarian)
Pennsylvania
Rep. Charles W. Dent of Allentown, Pennsylvania (15th District) Republican—2 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Siobhan L. “Sam” Bennett (Democratic)
Rep. Jim Gerlach of Chester Springs, Pennsylvania (6th District) Republican—3 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Bob Roggio (D)
Rep. Bill Shuster of Hollidaysburg, Pennsylvania (9th District) Republican—4 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Tony Barr (D)
South Carolina
Rep. J. Gresham Barrett of Westminster, South Carolina (3d District) Republican—3 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Jane Dyer (D)
Tennessee
Rep. Zach Wamp of Chattanooga, Tennessee (3d District) Republican—7 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Ed Choate (Independent)
Jean Howard-Hill (Independent)
Doug Vandagriff (D)
Texas
Rep. K. Michael Conaway of Midland, Texas (11th District) Republican—2 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
John R. Strohm (Libertarian)
Rep. Henry Cuellar of Laredo, Texas (28th District) Democrat—2 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
James ‘Jim’ Fish (R)
Ross L. Leone (Libertarian)
Rep. Al Green of Houston, Texas (9th District) Democrat—2 terms
Official Site
Opponent(s):
Brad Walters (Libertarian)
Rep. Sheila Jackson-Lee of Houston, Texas (18th District) Democrat—7 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
John ‘Johnny’ Faulk (R)
Mike Taylor (Libertarian)
Rep. Solomon P. Ortiz of Corpus Christi, Texas (27th District) Democrat—13 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Robert E. Powell (Libertarian)
Willie Vaden (R)
Rep. Mac Thornberry of Clarendon, Texas (13th District) Republican—7 terms
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Roger J. Waun (D)
Vermont
Rep. Peter Welch of Hartland, Vermont (At Large) Democrat—1 term
Official Site
Campaign Site
Opponent(s):
Mike Bethel (Independent)
Cris Ericson (Independent)
Thomas Hermann (Progressive)
Jane Newton (Liberty Union)
Jerry Trudell (Energy Independence)
[Did we fail to note a campaign, a campaign Web site, or anything else? Drop us a line.]
The Bailout Vote: Who Switched? - The WashingtonWatch.com Blog
[...] A Bailout Rogues Gallery . . .The Bailout Vote: Who Switched? Silly Season, Part IVBailout Bill in the House Rules CommitteeFollowing the Bailout Bills - And Their CostsSenate Passes Bailout Legislation [...]
ten billion butterfly sneezes » Cowardly Congress People
[...] a list of the Congress People who had a “change of heart”1 on the Bailout Bill, and went from non-support to support [...]
Wilson46201
Considering Congresslady Julia Carson died December 15, 2007, it’s highly doubtful she voted one way or another this week in Washington, DC.
What next? A post decrying Herbert Hoover for this bad economy? Keep up with the news!
Why bother to read this site if you can’t get basic facts like Congressional membership right?
Jim Harper
Good catch, Wilson46201. Thanks.
It was her grandson, Andre Carson, who should have gone up here. His name and image don’t yet appear in the Government Printing Office’s Congressional Pictorial Directory, so going to collect a picture of the “Carson” who represents Indiana’s 7th District got that result.
Pretty dumb error, I have to admit, but I’ve written before that I’m more focused on policy than politics and politicians. Not an excuse - just a plea that you’ll understand.
The Other Vote-Switcher - The WashingtonWatch.com Blog
[...] Other Vote-SwitcherWashingtonWatch.com Digest - October 6, 2008A Bailout Rogues Gallery . . .The Bailout Vote: Who Switched? Silly Season, Part IVBailout Bill in the House Rules [...]
Below The Beltway » Blog Archive » Just Call It The Judas List
[...] From Jim Harper comes this helpful and heavily annoted list of those members of the House of Representatives who voted “no” on the bailout bill on Sept… [...]
The Agitator » Blog Archive » Morning Links
[...] A gallery of congresscritters who switched votes on the bailout–as well as information about their opponents in November. You know, in case you wanted to express your feelings about their vote financially. [...]
Liberty or Bust | rights | liberty | privacy | politics | technology | economics | limited government
[...] Watch provided a list of bailout supporters. Since I am an Arizona resident, it is my duty to provide you with some direct links of candidates [...]
William Neal
WHAT? No one from my home state voted for it? I was born in Mississippi and have considered it along with the reste of the country for eons that it’s the most assbackward place in the union. FINALLY they did something RIGHT!! F-u’d to the govt. re. this bogus Financial Recovery Package, er, now, the Bailout Bail Out is law. Duh. Too late….
William Neal
Too bad there’s no edit option. Sucks, does this site. I wanted to say unequivocally: rest of the country, not: reste. I don’t think it’s a word. And the two spellings of Bail or Bailout…well, you know. What difference does it make now? NO one would listen and shred those three pages from the white house, and recycle the paper. Which is what should have happened.
Switch or Not: How Did Your Representative Vote? - The WashingtonWatch.com Blog
[...] Making this the All-Bailout BlogThe Other Vote-SwitcherWashingtonWatch.com Digest - October 6, 2008A Bailout Rogues Gallery . . .The Bailout Vote: Who [...]
The Bailout Vote - The WashingtonWatch.com Blog
[...] Making this the All-Bailout BlogThe Other Vote-SwitcherWashingtonWatch.com Digest - October 6, 2008A Bailout Rogues Gallery . . .The Bailout Vote: Who [...]
Vermonters! Don’t Vote Yet! We Have More Information for You! - The WashingtonWatch.com Blog
[...] wrote in to point us to his Web site, presumably for inclusion in the Bailout Rogue’s Gallery. Check it out [...]
Did Voters Punish Vote-Switchers and Financial-Crisis-Causers? - The WashingtonWatch.com Blog
[...] took a scythe to the Members of Congress who switched their votes to pass the financial services bailout legislation in October and those whose votes in 2000 set the [...]