What People Think
 |
 |
69% For, 31% Against
Take Action
| Vote on this Bill | |
  |
For |
  |
Against |
| Speak Out | |
  |
Comment on this Bill |
  |
Alert Your Friends and Colleagues |
  |
Write Your Representative in Congress |
| Save & Share | |
 |
del.icio.us |
 |
Digg |
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
 |
Yahoo! |
H.R. 623, The Second Chance for Ex-Offenders Act of 2007 (103 comments ↓)
H.R. 623 would permit expungement of records of certain nonviolent criminal offenses.
()
Learn More
Trackback URL: http://www.washingtonwatch.com/bills/trackback/110_HR_623.html
RSS Feeds for This Bill
Keep yourself updated on user contributions and debates about this bill! (Learn more about RSS.)
Visitor Comments
britt
It's about time. Jeez, one screw up and you're branded forever? If so, then why speak highly of this country then?
skone
I hope it passes. Non violent felons
are labeled and put on the same list as the mass murderer. And that is not right. I'm glad this problem is being looked at again and has a possibility of getting passed into law.
Fern
I feel as if I have to pay my debt to society for the rest of my life. I am not hired for jobs because I have to answer "Yes" have I ever been convicted of a felony. I hope this passes now, and not in another two years from when Mr. Rangle first introduced this in 2005.
Ziggy
Everyone deserves a "Second Chance"! This is great news for people to re-establish their lives.
Donna
Everybody deserves a second chance. Good luck to you Fern.
crimson
This bill also alows for people that have looked at violent material that is sexual in manner towards children as this is a federal crime as well while I believe that people deserve a second chance we also have to look at all the people that this bill will alow out. Looking at pics is not a violent crime, but could lead to one in the future that would not be considered a federal crime, but a state crime.
VAVibe
Simply letting our Congressmen know that "the people" would like to see this pass is a waste of time..just getting a letter from them thank us for writing. What can be really do to bring attention to this bill that deserves quick & valuable debate and not to get stuck in committee where it is now...not getting any attention?
Rob
If Rangel can't pull this one through the process, i don't think anyone can. The other bill, HR 1593 won't do didley for people with an education wanting to get a good job. What employer would hire someone with a criminal background unless all they were doing was washing the floor? Alas, i'm afraid, no one cares...
charlesidelsohnattorney@yahoo.com
pray
To crimson & others
crimson, if you read the bill in its entirety, you will see that not only does the offender have to meet many pre-requisites, but the petition MUST ALSO MUST BE APPROVED BY A JUDGE OR OTHER AUTHORITY. You can be sure if the offender was invloved in child anything, he/ she will never be approved for expungement.
Advocate for many reasons
Finding gainful employment as a convicted felon – irrespective of the nature of the crime - is near impossible, and continues to be long after debts to society have been paid. In substance, every convicted felon faces a life sentence with respect to employment, making leading a normal life an insurmountable task.
This Bill would, among other benefits would:
1. Provide hope, dignity, and motivation where there is none
2. Significantly reduce recidivism.
3. Reduce taxpayer burdens and government expenditures by:
3a. Reducing the number of felons seeking social services (welfare)
3b. Reducing the number of felons seeking government sponsored healthcare
3c. Reducing the costs associated with housing inmates
4. Reduce crime as felons would be able to find legal means of earning an income
5. Reduce unemployment
6. Help break the vicious cycle of crime and welfare as a way of life in certain communities.
K.B.
I can't urge this enough, this bill is exremely reasonable and well written.They hand out felonies/misdemeanors for very petty and unserious crimes.These convictions are serious labels and restrict any means of real life.Many people make mistakes, some get caught and others don't.You'd be surprised at what B.S.could get you a conviction with such serious consequences.If you read the bill you will see that only non-violent crimes would be eligible and if they screwed up again the expungement gets reversed.This could bring some great changes and relieve some very congested issues (i.e.,budget,prisons,welfare,unemployment,etc.)Please support this bill and urge others to do so!
la'treill
this bill needs to be put in effect immediately as there are too many people being falsly convicted for petty crimes and deserve a second chance
KL
I hope everyone gets together and writes a letter or do whatever necessary to get this bill passed. The system is messed up because a conviction leaves a mark on your name for life. PLEASE everyone put actions to your comments and prayers and get this bill into a law. Everybody deserves a second chance.
Charles Benninghoff
There is a very important article about the Second Chance Act for Ex-Offenders of 2007 printed on American Chronicle. The article details Congressman Rangel's comments on the bill and is a must-read to understand the emotion he brings to this critically important subject. The article can be found at: http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/viewArticle.asp?articleID=27951. If you truly want to work together to help pass HR 623, please read www.rehabilitated.org. It has many pages concerning this bill and how we can join together nationally to get this balming legislation on the books. If you have a conviction that is impacting your life - you can bet there are millions out there similarly situated. By joining TRP, your efforts can be leveraged to help all of them. Our recidivism rate is so high because we deprive ex-offenders of employment, education and social benefits otherwise available to everyone - even illegal aliens.
Bert 36
This Bill keeps stalling in the Judiciary Committee. It appears that our "friends" in Congress are more concerned about granting amnesty (Pardons)to Mexicans and other enemies of America who by the way have committed numerous Felonies than helping their fellow constituents .
It's a shame that there is no remedy to erase or get e Certificate of Rehabilitation for a non-violent federal conviction as it exist on the States level. So contact every member of the House Judiciary Committee and tell then to move this Bill and write letters to every Congressman/woman and U.S. Senator and tell them to do the same.
Don't be discouraged thought as in almost every State all voting rights have been restored except in Virginia if I'm correct.
We have to push Congress to pass this HR 623 and not to set it aside each time.
Having a lifetime criminal record on file with all the resulting liabilities is a cruel punishment and must be changed.
www.usapoliticaltyranny.info
RogerD
Can you believe that our Congress and President wants to let 12-20mil illegal aliens get 'amnesty' while non-violent felons, citizens of this country, are disenfranchised FOR LIFE.
That should tell you all something.
Eric D
I feel this bill is a very good first step in reducing recidivism. However, "Any crime" which happens to be a "first offense" should have an opportunity (if that person has proved rehabilitation) to get that record expunged. All ex-offenders need to should be able to feed their families. Should a person who was convicted of a Robbery and recieved 2 to 6 years in effect "actually" be sentenced to a "LIFE" sentence?
Is congressman Rangel saying that an ex-violent offender should not have a fear chance for employment? God Forbid. Why must there always be a "boogie man" when it comes to giving mostly black men a second chance?
SSB
This bill needs to be passed NOW!! This is AMERICA, should you be condemed for the rest of your life because of one non violent mistake!
I have paid my dues to society and then some. Having recently graduated from a university with a BS degree, I am learning quickly by answering "yes" to the dreaded convicted question, my application gets tossed, recruiter changes their tune, or interview stops.
If this bill passes maybe people like me that are trying to better themselves will have that "second chance!"
pessimistic...
I hate to be, but i feel no one is listening; no one cares except your family and others in the same boat. The politicians always have more important fish to fry. Take a look at the House Judiciary website and see what crap comes to floor. We don't have a chance.
MDK
This is truely a bill who's time has come. Having your chances of a normal life greatly reduced due to a non-violent crime that has been paid for makes no sense. In many cases it increases the strain on public assistance. Additionally, if we truely believe people can change, don't we need to give them a chance to?
Melissa
I think this is a great idea. Any person can change and should be given a chance to start anew.
Donna
I skimmed through this! This is Good!
I surely think it would be Great if a Judge had this Guideline-bill -Act to go through when dealing with these Non violent crimes!!
I guess in a lot of Non Violent crimes they pretty much have to throw the book at you because they have no choice in the matter!
Sometimes – No Mercy and that is Sad!!! There is too many Good People that deserve that second chance.
Yes- we happen to know one of those persons!
It is Sad when it is a persons first offense ever and they get convicted big time! I say “Yes” - they deserve a second chance !
This bill has strict Guidelines which is Good- It just doesn’t get them off scott free- they still have to keep it clean!
I think it is strict enough that it will help them keep it straight and it will help them into having a chance to live a normal life!
I know the jails and prison are so full = I would think this bill would be very helpful and I think it is very fair!!!
APRIL BIAS
MAJORITY OF THEM MISS OUT ON FAMILY, FRIENDS, ETC. EVERYONE MAKES MISTAKES AND THEY HAVE PAID THEIR DEBT TO SOCITEY. NOW IT IS TIME FOR THEM TO HAVE A LIFE BECAUSE WHEN YOU LOOK AT IT IN REALITY THEY HAVE ALREADY SPENT THEIR WHOLE LIFE IN PRISON AND ALL THEY DID WAS ROBBERY AND DIDN'T HARM THE PERSON. PLUS, THEY ARE ALSO TRIED AS MURDERS SOMETIMES AND I BELIEVE THAT SHOULD BE A DIFFERENT CATEGORY. PLEASE JUST LOOK MORE INTO IT AND I BET WHEN THEY GET PAROLE OR HOUSE ARREST THEY WOULD LOOK BACK AT THEIR LIVES AND WOULDN'T MAKE ANOTHER MISTAKE AGAIN BECAUSE PRISON ISN'T FOR ANYONE. IT WILL GIVE THEM HOPE, FAITH, AND A CHANCE TO SEE THINGS DIFFERENTLY. EVERYONE LOOKS AT A PERSON BAD BECAUSE THEY GO TO PRISON BUT, IN REALITY THERE ARE ALOT OF GOOD MEN THEIR WITH GOOD HEARTS AND THEY JUST MADE AN HONEST MISTAKE. THEY JUST NEED ANOTHER CHANCE AT LIFE. PLEASE CONSIDER PASSING THE BILL. GOD BLESS YOU ALL
Deborah
This is a much needed bill, especially for someone with a young child who needs to start over again. It is about time.
ZP
There was another bill 2005 ago with the same name (HR 622) which never made it. I have a bad feeling this won't go anywhere either.
Jeff
I was a rebellious youth and reached out for attention the only way I knew how, when I was very young. Now, I'm a completely different person, if you can see the difference between you at 18 and you at 30, it is no different for me.
But here I am at 30, I still have a job history of only being hired when I lie on my application and fired when I'm figured out. Twice I was not fired when figured out, instead the employer stopped paying me until I simply quit. Now I'm in College going for my Bachelor's and I'm afraid that, even is I can get my record expunged, my juvenile-looking work history will create further employment problems.
TBN
"Second Chance..."
It's great that we are finally identifying one of the reasons why individuals recidivate- I counsel the population in question and they are making positive decisions these days but still have a tough time accessing opportunities -
My number one concern about this issue is that, How is it that "White Collar ex-offenders' have a greater chance of securing career opportunities and regain access to financial benefits and all that comes with it - yet, others are barred for Life for their
"Low-Collar offenses"-
Last I checked if someone affected the family structure by selling narcotics and taking money from households are in no means less than when someone causes employees'at major businesses loss of jobs, benefits, savings etc..
Seems Equal to me...please advise
I guess my point is: They are able to re-start their lives and move on -
Akaia
Referred to the Subcommittee on Crime, Terrorism, and Homeland Security.
People, you must contact committee members, write letters to the editors of newspapers, Lou Dobbs on CNN, and call talk radio. We have got to start a national dialogue on this issue.
Brian
Well, what do ya know?! That socialist, Castro/Chavez sympathizing, gun banning, big taxing, pro-welfare state, caucasian hating, far, FAR left-wing a**hole Charles Rangel might be good for something after all!
Curious...
jeez Brian, why do you feel the need to make such a comment?
Response to TBN
TBN, it's not so much about 'White Collar' as it is 'non-violent'.
Many non-violent drug crimes seem to qualify. Though, it will probably be an issue on just what does qualify at the margin.
Please, Please, Please
In the erly eighties when I was 18 I was convited of a drug crime. I became a federal felon. I have never voted, had a real job, Owned a home, gotten a student load, goten married.
Pleasepass this bill. Dont ruin any more lives
Al 10
Now that the Second Chance Act House Bill 1074 has been passed by the Judiciary Committee today August 3,2007 and sent to the House for deliberation let's hope the other more important bill 623 will finally see the day and pass in the Judiciary Committee and eventually become a law.
As for the above poster you have not necessarily lost your right to vote. It depends on your State. Most States except for Virginia and Kentucky do not prevent people convicted of Felonies,whether State of federal, from voting.
Usually the right to vote and to run for office is returned upon either discharge from prison, or upon satisfying the probation requirement.
Write also to as many Congressman/women and Senators asking them to please pass this Bill 623 as on the Federal Level there are no other avenues to have a Certificate of Good Conduct or one of Certificate of Relief from Criminal Disabilities and none at all for expunging a Federal Criminal record.
Let's see 623
any word on how this bill is favored in congress?
M. Menzies
This bill is a good idea. People are not perfect and make mistakes. Then they grow up or move on and become productive, quality people. Finally, something from the government that rewards GOOD behavior.
623 wish
This is an excellent bill. It will help to reduce crime, improve the economy and promote education. The unfortunate reality is that ex felons don't have a lobby with a warehouse full of cash to get any attention paid to this bill. We are talking non violent one time offenders, lets show some compasion. Ex felons is the one group in the U.S. that doesn't have a voice. All I have is a prayer that this HR becomes law. it would allow me to get this drug conviction of my back from when I was 18, which by the way is not old enough to buy alcohol or gamble but certainly old enough to punished for the REST OF YOUR LIFE through economic means for a indescretion commited at that age. I pray and hope for HR 623 but know it next to impossible for this to become law in the next 10 years.
623 will change my life
Ten years ago as a 20 year-old kid I became a convicted felon because of a drug conviction. In the last 10 years I have graduated from a top college with honors, married an attorney and had 3 children. I own a home, pay taxes and live as a law-abiding citizen. I had my civil rights restored years ago so legally I can vote, serve on a jury and obtain a professional license. In reality, as soon as I disclose I am a convicted felon the door is shut in my face. I cannot obtain professional employment. I can't even volunteer at my child's school because now they require background checks. Thank God I have a supportive family. I can't even imagine how difficult and hopeless it is for people who don't have any support. Unfortunately, when we are young and dumb we don't realize how our actions are going to effect the rest of our lives. No matter how much I accomplish in my life I cannot overshadow the stigma of being a convicted felon.
KR
You guys are right having a felony in your record do leave a mark for life and they say ex felons can't get jobs look at the guy thats working for the governor he's an ex offender and i thought ex offenders ouldnt work for the governor but this guy have front row seats getting paid big money isn't that something for the people sake please pass this bill
Living the nightmare
My partner has a federal conviction and this bill is a ray of hope not only for them but for me as well. The federal government destroyed 35 years of good employement and deeds with the single conviction. I plan on writing to my representatives. This is almost life or death. If this passes, I have hope that someday, we can get back on our feet. Without it, our lives are ruined, financially and emotionally. I used to have respect for the law. This might change my mind, a little. Next we should work on the corrupt FBOP. Guards withhold meds from the sick, they keep food/items intended for inmates for themselves and there is Absolutely, positively, nothing you can do about it. It is a gestapo. I can't even begin to tell you. Please, support this bill, everyone. It could be you... really, it could.
Becky
Senator Joe Biden of Delaware has shown some interest in HR 623--Second Chance for Non-Violent Felons. EVERYONE WRITE, CALL, OR EMAIL JOE BIDEN. GET FRIENDS, RELATIVES & YOURSELF TO FLOOD HIS OFFICE SO WE CAN GET HELP.
Carol
Please pass this bill, my son when younger did some "STUPID" things and has been completely rehabiliatee. buttttt, he cannot find a job because of his record. HIs crimes were non violent. He is 27 now and just wants to get a job and be self sufficient. PLEASE PASS THIS BILL
Scott Silverman
THe San Diego Second Chance program. www.secondchanceprogram.org
Stands ready to help With Prisoner Re Entry..
Paul M Bouschet
Please pass the H.R.623 Bill.
It will allow people like myself too move ahead with their lives and not too be labeled or reminded of their crime every time we apply for a job. People do dumb things at times and for the most part, there is no justification for it. Some of us want a second chance, we owe it too our families,employers and too ourselves. I agree that if this bill passes we will see a slow decline in crime rates as well as incarcerations. Depending on the circumstances, an ex-felon can change and live a productive civil meaningful life. Maybe we should look at the offenders on a case by case basis then made a determination.
Paul
Dale
I think this is an awesome opportunity for those who have made a mistake in their life, learn from their mistake, and made the necessary corrections in the lives to not repeat those mistakes. Count me in for doing whatever it takes to get this passed. I'm definitely on board!!!
PASS IT NOW
THIS BILL MUST PASS. This will help so many to get jobs. With 70% of those released ending up back in the prison system doesn't it make sense to provide them with a second chance to improve their lives and that of their families. Wtite to your Congress and Senate, telling them to support this bill.
Irene from Texas
I hope this works out! So many people make bad choices and have to live with them forever. This is the perfect way for them to come back into society without beeing pointed with red flags everywhere they go. I pray this bill passes. This shout out is for you TIA MINDY!!!! LOVE YOU!!!!!!!!
R.R
I am praying that this bill will pass soon. This will give a whole lot of people hope for being restored to society.
Robert B
Yes, this act would in fact help people who were convicted, railroaded, or forced to plea bargain because of the way the "system" works. Especially persons who helped build this society and now theres nothing, we need to believe in the USA and think positive about what we can still do befor we die, maybe hating it!
Tony L.
You are so right, Robert B. Since this country is an 'it' and not a 'they', 'it' doesn't care if you hate it or love it; whether you've contributed or not. I am afraid you and I are now just smashed bugs on the windshields of the USA. Have you looked into moving to another country and contributing there? Seriously, why give this country any more of your blood, sweat or tears.
wontquit
I UNDERSTAND YOU ALL TOTALLY AND I HAVE BEEN DEALING WITH A FELONY FOR ABOUT 15 YEARS, PLEASE STOP BY MY PAGE I HAVE A PETITION UP AND SIGNING IT WILL HELP ALL THE WAY ROUND, WHETHER IT'S ON THE STATE OR FEDERAL LEVEL. THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT AND I WILL SUPPORT YOU!
www.myspace.com/wontquit
marie
This bill has died in the past and will die again. Why? In over a year only 51 comments on this website. It is election time. Write and talk to candidates. Maybe that will work. But this bill does not spend any money. It only helps people get a second chance. What politican wants to help. They only want to spend money. Our lives our over. We might as well dig a hole and crawl into it. Nobody cares. Noboday wants to help.
Nope
I hope this bill does not pass. When you do a crime, you need to pay the price. I don't want my children in a world with rapists and murderers roaming the street. People need to be responsible for their actions.
help_marie
Marie, as far as being a US citizen is concerned, you are correct -- your life is over. My suggestion? Try to see if it is viable for you to move to another country like, say, Mexico. Learn spanish, denounce your US citizenship and show the Mexican's how hard you want to be a member of their society. I think they are willing to give you the second chance that the US is not. I am not kidding. You/we all need to tell the USA we are sick and tired of their foot being on our necks for the rest of our lives EVEN AFTER WE HAVE PAID THE PRICE OF OUR TRANSGRESSION.
To Nope -- you're just an uneducated D*** and not worth commenting on -- you don't even know what the issue is. IT'S FOR NON-VIOLENT FELONY CHARGES WHERE NO ONE GOT HURT. GOT IT A******!!!!!???
Lillian
Oh most beautiflu flower of Mt Carmel fruitful vine splendor of Heaven Blessed Mother of the Son of God Immaculate virgin assist me in my necessity. Oh Star of the Seas help me and show me you are my Mother.Oh Holy Mary Mother of God Queen of Heaven and Earth I humbly beseech you from the bottom of my heart to succour me in my necessary. There are none that can withstand your power.Oh Mary conceived without sin pray for us who have recourse to thee.(3)Holy Mary I place this prayer in your hands.(3)Amen I thank you for passing Hr 623 getting me a job in January 2008 and winning the mega millions lottery jackpot.
Humility
It appears some of us haven't learned from our mistakes, the ones that got us in the position we are in today. Others judged us, however we disagree, and now we use hateful judgements against those trying to help us, such as Congressman Rangel. I guess the true test is in the character, whether a person is truly repentant.
Father in heaven, I pray that your mercy is poured on all these here and others throughout this land, who are in desparate need for this bill HR 623 to become law.
We have sinned, and seek Your forgiveness, we need Your saving grace, and ready salvation.
Lord nothing is too hard for You, and I ask that You dumbfound all by passing this law in 2008.
Create in us a new life, that begins with Your son Jesus, allow us to be made whole and know that it was You who freed us from our chains.
We give You thanks and glory in anticipation of your mighty salvation.
In Jesus' mighty name, the name above every name, I ask this, amen.
Reality
I praise rangel for all he does. And to all of you who are like me and know we are still in a prison without bars go on and never give up. I have watched this go to subcommittee and fail since 2001. Look back you will see. But work even if it is door to door never go back even if you must starve first. we must be peaceful and law abiding for it is the only way. But when you can take no more and know you are at your limit go to washington dc and in a peaceful way show your pain. eventfully the media will see and will show our plight until it is in the minds of congress and the people we are lost to the world.
Remember
Never give up !
Never surrender!
Freedom !
JR413
Hey NOPE- we are talking about NON-Violent crimes, not rapists and murders. People like you and me, just the ones that have been caught. I'm sure you've made a stupid mistake in your past. An addict should get help, not 10-15 years and a life-sentence of poverty. The ignorance of people like you are what will stop this bill from getting passed, leaving more families on public assistance and more second time offenders. Without a decent job to support your family, it is hard not to want to turn back to the streets out of pure desperation. This act is beneficial to everyone, not just the criminals. The money we'll save on the lower number of welfare recipients can be used for MANY other things, including helping the community your kids go to school in! Read more into the bill. There is no down fall, and no rapists or murders on the street.
jr413
THIS BILL WAS PRESENTED TO THE HOUSE ON 1/22. IT WAS REFERRED TO THE HOUSE JUDICIARY, SUBCOMMITTEE ON CRIME, TERRORISM, AND HOMELAND SECURITY.
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/committee.xpd?id=HSJUGO
THIS SITE HAS THE NAMES OF THE OFFICIALS IN THIS COMMITTEE AND THE EACH PERSON REPRESENTING EACH STATE. GO THERE, FIND YOURS AND WRITE TO THEM!! THEY ARE YOUR VOICE IN THE HOUSE, SO LET THEM KNOW YOUR OPINION. IT IS THEIR JOB TO DO AS WE WANT!!! WE VOTED FOR THEM!!!!
JR413
SORRY, TRY THIS LINK
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill=h110-623
AND CLICK ON THE LINK FOR THE House "Judiciary, Subcommittee on Crime, Terrorism, and Homeland Security"
TO FIND YOUR REPRESENTATIVES.
debs
IT IS ABOUT TIME WE ALL GET INVOLVED TO HELP OUT FOR ALL CONCERNED.NOT ONLY IS THE ADULT FOREVER PUNISHED, THE CHILDREN ARE ALSO IN THE MIX.
ken
to nope..you can't be real.your mentality went out with the borgias.to help_marie.mexico's not the place.i tried it for 3 yearsafter release for growing pot.any mexican can come to amerika andbuy property wherever he wants.in mexico as a gringo i can't own property within 100 kms of salt water or an international border.a greencard (permanent residency in the us is free.in mexico it's $100us every year.other laws ae just as tilted there are however, other more friendly countries.one of which is my new patria
Fed-Up
Society preaches rehabilitation but yet continues to prosecute and penalize those individuals that are truly trying to make something of their lives for the support of themselves and their children. Give these people a chance for a decent life and pass this bill!
JR413 or anyone else: What can I do to make a difference? I have sent letters to my representatives on this issue but I have no representatives on this subcommitte - can I still contact these members to voice my opinion?
to_ken
Ken, can you finish your thoughts on a good country to emmigrate to? As to owning property in Mexico, doesn't one own property through a Mexican corporation? Baja condos are mostly owned by gringos from SoCal. Isn't that how they do it? Take care bro...
ken
to:to_ken
yes, i can finish my rantings.for 3 years i lived in a barrio outside of la paz mexico.i had a few good mexican friends,but found an underlying bias against gringoes.theyre still mad about the mex-amer war.as for holding property there in a mexican corporation;any time youhave to deal with the mexican legal system,you are at a disadvantage.remember they're using the napoleanic code,ie there is a preupposition of guilt.this also applies to civil law.also since you need to apply for a new (permanent residence) visa every year there's too much chance of criminal history coming to light.it.s just too much of a hassle.other places you could consider would be the dominican republic or panama where the almost valueless us dollar is legal tender.where ever you decide to go you should do it asap.big brother is expanding his computer file capabilities.soon the door will be closed unless hr 623 can get passed.if that happens the door will be open tomany other places...ken
Sarah
Even as a former prosecutor I cant , I am praying for this bill to pass. It is so important to keep our society functioning.
I had a client in private practice who had been convicted of federal theft of property valued at a mere $200 in 1992. He has never been arrested for anything else in his life. He has never had any unpaid traffic fines, had held long term employment (for the federal governemnt no less), paid taxes, and contributed to the economic flow of society. After pleading guilty, the man paid immediate restitution, was placed on probation and was even allowed to keep his job for the federal government. Now, 16 years later (and after layoffs by the feds), he cant find a job, cant vote, cant go hunting with his family, etc. This is the perfect example of someone who broke the law, was punished accordingly, paid his debt and should be able to move on with his life.
vp
I pray that all of you find happinesss, courage ,strength, and keep God foremost. because if God is for you, who can be against you?
Allisio Rex
The only practical way to get this Bill move forward is to mobilize by the hundreds and go to Washington,D.C and demonstrate in front of the Judiciary Committee, the entire Congress and the U.S. Senate.
We will have to organize with the help of Charles Benninghoff and just take off one day when the Congress in in Session with banners and speak loud and clear to those insensitive dictators and express our grievances.
Millions of illegal aliens did it, even though they had No rights, we should be able to do it too otherwise this Bill will take decades to resolve.
Those who are not willing to take one day off then they will have only themselves to blame! Wake up.
unforgiven
This bill must move forward. We are losing too many productive wage earners because of the extemely punitive effect of a criminal conviction long after the person has served their punishment and sentence.
Bettye
I am a Mother of a violent-crime offender,my question is if it is not intended to help the violent- crime offenders. What will happen to them when they are finally released from prison. NO EDUCATION while they incarcerated, what is the point of releasing that person.Sounds like they are setting up a particular set of rules for people who need it the most. CONVICTIONS OF ANY CRIME SHOULD BE LOOKED AT WITH EVERY AVENUE TO RE-ENTERATE back into Society,with the skills are be made available the individual a second chance.I am willing to fight for my son to work hard and go back to school This is why we need to have inplace organizations to help the individual who was convicted of a violent-crime such as CRACK COCAIN POSESSION.They need assistance also, look at this way what's the difference of powder cocain,crack cocain.One is just as BAD as the Other.
Shame
I was convicted of a drug crime in 1982 and served 5 months in a federal. Since being released, I have obtained a Master's degree and dedicated my life to helping others. I have always indicated my conviction on job applications, but these jobs have been obtained through friends . But more recently as I have applied for jobs with schools and hospitals, the door is closed in my face.
unforgiven
Write the members of the House Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime, Terror and Homeland Security. H.R. 623 is currently with that committee for review, but it will not get any movement unless people urge their representatives to support it. Go to this website: http://www.govtrack.us/congress/committee.xpd?id=HSJU. If any of these people are in your state, fax or call them. They will respond to your request. ALso,contact the representatives for your state and ask them to cosponsor the bill. Now is a good time since the Senate just passed another Second Chance Act aimed at reducing recidivism.
Good luck!
Tony N.
There are lots of people out there who are turn away from a job interview because they've committed a non-violent felony who deserves a 2nd chance in life. One mistake should not be the end of your career in America. Everyone deserves a 2nd chance. Please pass this bill!
Tom J.
Thank God for Charlie Rangel and his courage. Support H.R. 623. Call your congressmen, tell them that this matters to the voters.
Topgunner
Rich and powerful people already have access to a second chance, or third or fourth. If you have enough influence, you can receive a pretrial adjudication - and not be charged for a crime if you comply with a probationary sentence. However, that option is not available for most people - and the result is a lifetime of being labelled and unable to redeem themselves.
Jeffery W.
Why isn't this bill moving forward? Its a good law and will give people a chance to be working and contributing to this country. It will actually reduce crime because people who might have made one mistake, a nonviolent mistake, can go to work and support themselves instead of needing help all the time or becoming desparate.
Anders
Pray for this resolution.
GiantsFan
Its about time for this...too many ruined lives that could be built up again. This is a good idea. How to make it happen in my lifetime?
GermanMann
I know 2 people who could get work if they could just get a second chance with a cleared record and some fair treatment. HR623 is a good idea and fair and decent. maybe it will pass this time.
Eugene From Illinois
I see H.R 1593 Second Chance Act passed this year but there is no mention of Federal Expundgement. Comparable criminal offenses whether at the State or Federal level you would think would have like similar punish consequences, and most research show that they do.
However at the State level, a person has the opportunity to petition to have his/her criminal record expunged; there is no avenue at the Federal to do the same. Surely inequity exists; although different systems, same or like offense, same Country, same demographics, appear unjust and all indicators say there is no equity in justice in parallel systems designed primarily to rehabilitate the offender.
GermanMann
The equity (or inequity) situation is a good point. Barriers to becoming fully rehabilitated exist for federal offenders, regardless of how much time has passed or how relatively small the offense. State offenders at least have some incentive to rebuild their lives and seek employment, but the person with a federal conviction has to jump a hurdle that is impossible.
couldbeyou
If you think a conviction just happens to so-called "bad" people then think again...it could happen to anybody just like that. errors happen in court and sometimes people get railroaded or get convicted for acting in selfdefense. it could happen to you. everybody needs this bill. it can only help, not hurt anyone.
Topgunner
This is just sensible, and way overdue. The judicial system isn't respected in this country because it is entirely uneven. The powerful and rich get ways around convictions on their records, the majority of people branded with any kind of conviction are either poor or middle class. It's Not for murderers and multimillion dollar embezzlers, the second chance act is for people who have suffered excessively from a much earlier mistake, or who may have even been falsely convicted.
texas2step
is there some kind of group pushing for this new bill to get approved? maybe it needs an organized effort or lobby to make it happen. its about time.
EE BRASWELL
NOW ALL THE YOUNG PEOPLE JUST THINKING ABOUT BREAKING THE LAW CAN SAY DONT WORRY BE HAPPY I CAN DO THE CRIME AND THE THIS LAW WILL GIVE ME A BREAK IF I GET CAUGHT THIS IS A GREAT COUNTRY WHEN I WAS YOUNG I WORE THE SAME 3 SETS OF CLOTHES UNTILL I GOT A CHANCE TO WASH THEM DONT YOU DARE TELL ME OR A LOT OF MY FRIENDS WHO REFUSED TO BREAK THE LAW YOU ARE GOING TO LET THESE IDIOTS GET A NEW DEAL
couldbeyou
EEBRASWELL, Rest assured that people who do get convicted of a crime are being punished. In addition to their sentence, they face many years of being disenfranchised. This bill just offers hope to good people who want to constructively rebuild their lives and not be literally punished for the rest of their lives, along with their families. No one is getting a free ride here.
broken
If you read this, take about an hour to find out who your representative is, and write them a letter or a fax or an email and tell them you expect their support of this bill. These people are elected by us and they need to listen to what we want done. Don't be afraid to let them know. Call their office and ask for the staff member who handles feedback from voters or issues on the judiciary committees. Its their job.
Ablebodied
Its about time we got something like this. Too many people cant find work who would be glad to be earning a living for them and their family. I hope people will see how much good Rangel's bill can bring.
indeedpayingthepricenow
I made some mistakes when i was younger and i did my time for it. After release it has been increasingly more difficult for me to work. I'm well educated but the brand of "Felon" is more than enough to put employers off. Let me tell you, the punishment of time spent is more than you could ever know. Unless you have been there, you couldn't possibly know. It impacts you, your family, everyone around you. It disenfranchises you from the society as a whole. If we as felons have paid our debt to society, I would like to believe that we deserve to be treated as full members of society again. Sadly, this is not true, I am a member of a group that is permanently branded. When you leave prison the joke is always "we will see you when you come back" and the worst part is there is far too much truth to that joke. Please call and contact your representatives, the vast majority of felons are convicted for minor drug offenses and white collar crimes. Give us a chance.
Sadly ain't gonna happen
Even the founder of www.rehabilitated.org declared that it's hopeless. He has better visibility into this thing than most.
Again i say, either storm the halls of the capitol en masse or find another country with which to dedicate yourself and your sweat to 'cause it ain't happening here.
The USA sucks.
notgivingup
I can't give up on this bill. It's my only hope for getting back to work.
Brian D.
Well doing nothing will leave you stuck in limbo anyway so you might as well do what ever you can. I cant storm the halls of the capitol because I can't just go to Washington with a family here a thousand miles away but I will keep on trying to send messages to my representatives, and at least some of them will hoepfully listen to the people.
broken
Some of these comments are from people who committed a minor crime over 25 years ago, but they are still being punished for a lifetime. There's no reason for it to be this way. HR623 is a sane way to begin solving some of our problems with inequalities in the justice system, recidivism and a cycle of joblessness and poverty.
Steve
If 1 in 100 Americans are in jail or on parole, then I wonder how many are in "no mans land" in between with an old conviction they can't rise above. I'll bet it's a pretty high number. What would happen if just half of those people could get back to being a full American, with good jobs and a way to support their families. Why would anybody not want something good like this to happen.
GeorgeG
this will get people back to work who really want to support themselves.
Jenny
I hope this passes. My son can not join the Marine Corp because of the stupid stuff he done as a teen. He want to protect this great country now but can't.
Abby
The only way to get this passed soon is for all of the x felons to march in Washington ,DC---Someone has to become a leader and get all of this started.It's a shame that the US treats citizens that committed a crime and paid their punishment and are branded forever-the rich x felons still have money and can make more money(Barbara Stewart)(Michael Vick)--Look at the Madam in Florida--Prison sentence plus they took everything she had?If you are convicted on conspiracy--they take your money-house--the government is out of control--
william fitts
i too have aproblem its a misdemenor assault 1day in jail no fine happend 1995 an now just showed up on a gun purhace 2008 local courts never turned in an according to my judge;who is ahouse rep now said it would never effect my 2 nd amendment rights an now im in trouble with the feds this law will be of great help for some of us i hope
Kennedy
I think that passing this law would be wonderful. It is nice to finally have some reprive from this ordeal. I am a college graduate and find it hard to get a decent job because my exboyfriend lied to me and got me in trouble.
Realize this...
If YOU haven't sent a fax to YOUR congressman in YOUR state, this bill doesn't have a chance to pass.
Got it? Everyone is waiting on everyone else to make this happen -- that won't work.
Answer this simple question: "Have i faxed my congressman?" If the answer is NO -- then you are just dreaming that others will make it happen for you and that one day you'll just wake up, after having done NOTHING, and this bill will have auto-magically have passed.
AIN'T GONNA HAPPEN -- HERE'S WHY. UNDERSTAND THAT NON-FELONS OF THE UNIVERSE DON'T UNDERSTAND YOUR PAIN LIKE YOU DO AND WON'T GO THE EXTRA MILE LIKE YOU HAVE TO IN ORDER TO MAKE IT HAPPEN.
Not to mention that we face tremendous headwinds in a society bent on the old testament doctrine of JUDGEMENT rather than the new testament doctrine of FOREGIVENESS.
Now, go find out who your congressman are and SEND THEM A FAX TODAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You're reading the next message
...instead of SENDING YOUR FAX TO YOUR CONGRESSMAN!!!
NOW GO AND SEND YOUR FAX!!!!!
nonviolent
I agree with this law. Why do you have to be punished for the rest of your life for one mistake that did not hurt anyone else? If you have a conviction of any kind on your record - that's a life sentence! you might as well just give up. I think some people like the idea of permanent punishment, it makes them feel superior, but if you want people to get back to work, or go into the armed forces and support this country, you would also want this bill to pass. It costs nothing, but pays back good things to society.
yes, I'll send a fax to my congressman.
kennedy
To Nope, I can't believe how close minded you are. This bill is not aimed to expunge the record of rapists and murders. It is to help first time non violent offenders have a fair shot at getting a decent job. What is your problem. I made a mistake of trusting someone and ended up with a felony. That does not make me a bad person. I have a college degree and graduate tomorrow with an MBA. There are lots of people out there who made a mistake once and are being punished for it for their entire life. I hope no one in your family ever has to face this because they sure wouldn't be able to count on you for support. I heard that Bush signed the bill on April 9th. Don't know what this means yet. Hope it is good though.